Apology or NOT: How Ingabire Victoire Negotiated her Freedom from Rwanda Prison

L-R: Ingabire Victoire Umuhoza, lawyer Gatera Gashabana, Alice Muhirwa and Martin Ngoga.

About two months before the official opening of her trial in 2011 at the High Court of Rwanda in Kigali on serious charges including ethnic divisionism, Ingabire Victoire Umuhoza sought a private meeting with Prosecutor General Martin Ngoga.

Ngoga is currently the Speaker of the East African Legislative Assembly (EALA) based in Arusha, Tanzania. In early April 2011, a year after her arrest, prosecutors led by Alain Mukurarinda had filed all documents with court and were waiting for trial date.

But instead of preparing for her defense, Ingabire secured a secret meeting with Ngoga. It was held on April 8. Inside the one-on-one session, without the knowledge of her lawyers Gatera Gashabana and Briton Ian Edwards, Ingabire spoke candidly about her case.

Ingabire told Ngoga that she wanted to enter a “plea bargain”. She proposed to the Prosecutor General that she would plead guilty to some facts contained in the charges. In exchange, Ingabire demanded that Ngoga give her assurances that he would drop some of the charges.

The details of their conversation on that day are contained in thousands of pages of court documents filed with the High Court, and later in the Supreme Court.

Caught off-guard, Ngoga told Ingabire that the time for plea bargain had elapsed. Ingabire had for months after her arrest been persuaded to admit to the cases, which could have ultimately led to no charge filed or alternatively led to less time in prison. But she refused.

Some details of what transpired on that day were picked from court documents and published in a book by case prosecutor Mukurarinda.

Ngoga “informed her that this was no longer his area of responsibility since the case had been transferred to the High Court for judgment on its merits, and that if she wanted to plead guilty she could only do so before that Court,” writes Mukurarinda, on page 194 of the book.

The French publication, “Qui Manipule Qui?” – a rare insight into the huge volumes of court documents has turned Mukurarinda into an “Ingabire specialist” sought after for appearance at conferences outside Rwanda and media interviews.

In equal measure, Mukurarinda is subject of angry insults from exiled members of Ingabire’s political group. He has been called all sorts of names. Some have openly threatened him on social media and blogs. In interviews, he often laughs at the vitriol thrown at him.

In the secret meeting, Ingabire replied to Ngoga that she could not plead guilty publicly before the Court, because that would be tantamount to betraying her supporters. There is no court-recorded analysis of what Ingabire was thinking in telling Ngoga this, but it is openly clear she wanted a deal from Ngoga that would allow her maintain a ‘high profile’.

“Madame Victoire Ingabire Umuhoza”

From the April 8 meeting, Ingabire returned to her jail cell at the maximum security facility “1930”, which has since been closed. For Ngoga’s part, he did not reveal the meeting to his prosecutors – expecting Ingabire was going to prepare her plea and present it to court. No other Ingabire-Ngoga meeting happened.

The following month on May 16, Ingabire appeared in court for start of the trial charged with giving financial support to a terrorist group, planning to cause state insecurity and promoting ethnic divisionism. A lot has been written about these charges and we will not go into them for now.

The case would feature all over international pages and broadcasts. President Kagame was branded dictator preventing a woman from challenging him. The case was adjourned several times as Ingabire’s defense team raised hurdle after hurdle.

Then on April 16, 2012 – a year later, the High Court bench received a three-page handwritten document. It was a letter closed at bottom with “Madame Victoire Ingabire Umuhoza” and a signature.

The prosecution told court that the letter was submitted to show the bad faith being exhibited by Ingabire and her team. Prosecution accused Ingabire of using delaying tactics to drag the case on well aware it will stay in the media spotlight in her favour.

It turns out that Ingabire had penned a private letter to President Paul Kagame with a subject “Gusaba Imbabazi”. Right from the court session of that day, up until today, Ingabire admits she wrote a letter to Kagame, but angrily dismisses any suggestion it was an apology seeking clemency.

The Prosecutor General Ngoga could not, in any case, commit the error of asking Ms. Ingabire for an admission of guilt, as he was not unaware that the trial had started on the 16th May 2011 and that, according to the law, had been removed from the case file as soon as it had been sent to the Court for judgment on its merits and could in no case negotiate a “bargaining plea”.

Ingabire expected the prosecution to have been weak and wanted to muzzle them into playing by her tunes. Instead, Ngoga never accepted any of her other requests for meetings, according to court data.

Surprisingly, when the prosecution filed in the High Court the secret letter in which Ingabire was seeking presidential clemency, she went into overdrive. Inside the court session on that day, her Rwandan lawyer was so disappointed. After the session, he threatened to withdraw from her defence team if his client continued doing things behind his back.

Later on that same day April 16, 2012, Ingabire’s political grouping FDU-Inkingi released a statement announcing that Ingabire had “decided to withdraw, with immediate effect, from the show trial”. She said she would not attend any more sessions.

FREE: Ingabire Victoire walks out of Mageragere prison in Kigali. In total 2,140 inmates were freed from various jails around Rwanda

Personal confidante Alice Muhirwa

Ingabire’s group released a series of other statements claiming that the supposed letter to Kagame was a fabrication. As for the meeting with Ngoga, Ingabire’s team claimed it had been him who asked for the meeting not her. She gave a completely opposite version of what transpired between her and Ngoga.

Perhaps aware that Ingabire was trying to play a political game on a legal issue before a court of law, the prosecution kept silent. There was no public comments on the Ingabire letter to Kagame or her meeting with Ngoga. Instead, a short statement from them at the time said the prosecution would not discuss the case because that was illegal. They basically refused to be dragged into Ingabire’s game.

KT Press can now reveal that Ingabire revealed the Kagame letter to one person: Alice Muhirwa, who was her secretary and confidante. It is this lady who brought Ingabire food daily to the prison.

Case prosecutor Mukurarinda also confirmed in his book that Muhirwa was told about the clemency letter.

Here is how he explained: “Ms. Ingabire admits that all her attempts at denial have encountered unexpected obstacles, so much so that the damage caused by this secret correspondence has been enormous. Ms. Ingabire tried to explain this to Alice, who brought her food every day. She handed her the copy of the letter, explaining that she had never pleaded guilty. She begged her to have confidence in her, but in vain. The latter did not even deign to have any awareness of the letter.”

After the unsuccessful meeting, it is now clear Ingabire decided to send a letter to the President of the Republic, and not to the Prosecutor General Martin Ngoga, who had not even been sent a copy for information. No one will ever know what was on Ingabire’s mind when sending this letter, but she forgot that he couldn’t do anything about her plight even if he wanted to because the law stipulates that Presidential clemency can only be granted after all legal avenues have been exhausted.

Despite Ingabire’s protests against the High Court proceedings, her case continued. In October of that year 2012, she was found guilty and sentenced to eight years.

Prosecution dismissed the jail sentence as lenient and filed an appeal to the Supreme Court. In December of that year, Ingabire also submitted her appeal to the same court. Prosecution was demanding not less than 25 years behind bars and Ingabire wanted all charges thrown out entirely.

Controversial defense Witness AA

In December 2013, the Supreme Court made its decision – ruling that her defense filings were manipulations of the facts. Some of her defense grounds were described as conspiracy theories.

For example, Ingabire filed that her lawyer Gatera Gashabana had been part of a complex machinery working to convict her. Ingabire brought a strange witness to her defence who is only identified in the case documents as AA. The identity of the witness remains under wraps until today as per the orders of the High Court.

Witness AA’s testimony was of paramount importance to Ingabire and her defence. It was going to show the High Court how agents of the State – namely the intelligence services, the police, the Public Prosecutor, in connivance  with one of Ingabire’s  co-accused Vital Uwumuremyi, had committed serious acts under criminal law, crimes for which they could even be prosecuted.

According to this theory, all these people within the various State institutions, had devised a conspiracy to unjustly arrest, prosecute and convict Ingabire before the courts.

According to Witness   AA, the conspiracy took place in the northern part of the country, in a depot in the Mutobo transit camp where the witness lived and which, at the same     time, served as a dispensary for sick refugees returning to Rwanda. Witness AA stated that the conspiracy took place in the presence of at least fourteen other people.

The most astonishing   evidence in Witness AA’s testimony, is that when Ingabire’s defence, for whom she was supposed to testify, asked her questions, she revealed that at least one member of Ingabire’s defence had known about this conspiracy and had done so long before she was prosecuted!

It turns out later during questioning in the Supreme Court that witness was not credible. At the end of her (AA) testimony and despite the fact that they were part of the same team, when Gatera Gashabana put various questions to her, Witness AA did not hesitate to challenge Gatera Gashabana’s assertions, thus     proving them to be false. Indeed, in her responses to the Supreme Court, witness AA totally contradicted this conspiracy theory that Gatera Gashabana had just presented to the judges.

One of the contradictions uncovered about the witness AA is that she claimed it was Gatera who looked for her. Yet, under oath, she had revealed in written submissions that she is the one who initiated contact with Ingabire’s team because she knew of a “state conspiracy” against Ingabire. What Gatera only did was to travel to Northern Province to meet the witness and start preparing her to testify.

Three letters NOT one

Fast forward to 2018 and Ingabire has changed her story about whether she wrote any letter to President Kagame. In a completely surprising move, on the late evening of September 14 this year, a cabinet meeting granted clemency to Ingabire and singer Kizito Mihigo and pardoned 2,138 other prisoners.

Nobody expected this. Ingabire was back in the news. But this time with a new twist. It is not just one letter that Ingabire wrote to Kagame, it is actually two!

Ingabire hand-wrote three-page letter dated November 6, 2011 titled “Gusaba imbabazi”. Then she wrote another on May 25, 2018 also titled “Gusaba Imbabazi”. KT Press has established that following this second letter, Ingabire was informed in an official response from the Justice Ministry on September 14 that indeed government had received her letters and was going to grant her clemency. The same day, cabinet decided on her fate. She was freed the following day at 9am – along with all the others.

Ingabire admits she did write to Kagame, but refutes the letters were an apology and seeking clemency. In interviews with British broadcaster BBC, American VOA & Germany’s DW, Ingabire remains defiant.

The letters are in Kinyarwanda, and English or French translations bring more controversy. It will have to be left to history to be the judge.

 




Leave a Comment

adana escort adapazarı escort adıyaman escort afşin escort afyon escort ağrı escort ahlat escort akçaabat escort akçakale escort akçakoca escort akdeniz escort akhisar escort aksaray escort akşehir escort aksu escort akyazı escort alanya escort alaşehir escort aliağa escort altıeylül escort altınordu escort amasya escort anamur escort ankara escort antakya escort antalya escort araklı escort ardahan escort ardeşen escort arnavutköy escort atakum escort avanos escort avcılar escort aydın escort ayvacık escort ayvalık escort aziziye escort babaeski escort bafra escort bağcılar escort bağlar escort balıkesir escort bandırma escort bartın escort batıkent escort batman escort battalgazi escort bayburt escort belek escort besni escort beylikdüzü escort beyşehir escort biga escort bilecik escort bingöl escort birecik escort bismil escort bitlis escort bodrum escort bolu escort bor escort bornova escort boyabat escort bozüyük escort buca escort bucak escort bulancak escort bulanık escort bünyan escort burdur escort bursa escort çan escort çanakkale escort canik escort çankaya escort çankırı escort çarşamba escort çayeli escort çekmeköy escort çerkeş escort çerkezköy escort çeşme escort ceyhan escort çivril escort çorlu escort çorum escort çubuk escort çukurova escort çumra escort dalaman escort darıca escort datça escort davutlar escort defne escort denizli escort derince escort develi escort didim escort digor escort dinar escort diyadin escort diyarbakır escort doğanşehir escort doğubayazıt escort dörtyol escort dulkadiroğlu escort düzce escort edirne escort edremit escort efeler escort elazığ escort elbistan escort emirdağ escort erbaa escort erdemli escort ereğli escort erenler escort ergani escort ergene escort erzincan escort erzurum escort escort esenler escort eskil escort eskişehir escort espiye escort eyyübiye escort fatih escort fatsa escort fethiye escort finike escort fındıklı escort gaziantep escort gaziemir escort gebze escort gediz escort gelibolu escort gemerek escort gemlik escort gerede escort giresun escort gölbaşı escort gölcük escort görele escort görükle escort göynük escort gümbet escort gümüşhane escort güngören escort güroymak escort gürsu escort hakkari escort haliliye escort hatay escort haymana escort horasan escort iğdır escort ilgaz escort i̇lkadım escort i̇negöl escort i̇skenderun escort isparta escort i̇stanbul escort i̇zmir escort i̇zmit escort i̇znik escort kadirli escort kadıköy escort kağıthane escort kağızman escort kahta escort kaman escort kangal escort kapaklı escort karabük escort karacabey escort karahayıt escort karaköprü escort karaman escort karatay escort karesi escort kars escort karşıyaka escort kartal escort kaş escort kastamonu escort kaynaşlı escort kayseri escort keçiören escort kemer escort kepez escort keşan escort keskin escort kestel escort kilis escort kırıkhan escort kırıkkale escort kırkağaç escort kırklareli escort kırşehir escort kızıltepe escort kocaeli escort kocasinan escort konak escort konya escort konyaaltı escort körfez escort korkuteli escort köyceğiz escort kozan escort kumluca escort kumru escort kuşadası escort kütahya escort lara escort lüleburgaz escort malatya escort malazgirt escort malkara escort maltepe escort mamak escort manavgat escort manisa escort maraş escort mardin escort marmaris escort melikgazi escort menemen escort menteşe escort meram escort mersin escort merzifon escort mezitli escort milas escort mucur escort mudanya escort mudurnu escort muğla escort muratpaşa escort muş escort mut escort nazilli escort nevşehir escort niğde escort niksar escort nilüfer escort nizip escort nurdağı escort ödemiş escort of escort oltu escort onikişubat escort ordu escort orhangazi escort ortahisar escort ortaköy escort osmancık escort osmangazi escort osmaniye escort palandöken escort pamukkale escort pamukova escort patnos escort payas escort pazar escort pazarcık escort pendik escort polatlı escort rize escort safranbolu escort şahinbey escort sakarya escort salihli escort samandağ escort samsun escort sandıklı escort şanlıurfa escort sapanca escort sarıçam escort sarıkamış escort sarıyer escort şarkışla escort şehitkamil escort selçuklu escort selim escort serdivan escort serik escort seyhan escort siirt escort silifke escort simav escort sincan escort sinop escort şişli escort sivas escort siverek escort şırnak escort söğüt escort söke escort soma escort sultangazi escort suluova escort sungurlu escort sur escort suruç escort suşehri escort susurluk escort talas escort tarsus escort taşova escort tavşanlı escort tekirdağ escort terme escort tire escort tirebolu escort tokat escort torbalı escort toroslar escort trabzon escort turgutlu escort turhal escort türkoğlu escort tuzla escort ulus escort ümraniye escort ünye escort ürgüp escort urla escort uşak escort üsküdar escort üzümlü escort van escort varto escort viranşehir escort yahşihan escort yahyalı escort yakutiye escort yalova escort yatağan escort yenişehir escort yeşilyurt escort yıldırım escort yıldızeli escort yomra escort yozgat escort yunusemre escort yüreğir escort zara escort zeytinburnu escort zile escort zonguldak escort Aydın escort muğla escort tekirdağ escort manisa escort balıkesir escort manavgat escort alanya escort fethiye escort didim escort trabzon escort elazığ escort ordu escort kütahya escort ısparta escort rize escort maraş escort yalova escort giresun escort yozgat escort tokat escort şanlıurfa escort sivas escort batman escort erzurum escort sinop escort kırşehir escort karaman escort kırıkkale escort bolu escort amasya escort niğde escort uşak escort edirne escort çorum escort osmaniye escort zonguldak escort van escort erzincan escort söke escort nazilli escort kuşadası escort efeler escort didim escort çine escort bodrum escort fethiye escort marmaris escort dalaman escort menteşe escort milas escort ortaca escort seydikemer escort çerkezköy escort çorlu escort ergene escort kapaklı escort malkara escort süleymanpaşa escort akhisar escort alaşehir escort salihli escort şehzadeler escort soma escort turgutlu escort yunusemre escort bandırma escort altıeylül escort ayvalık escort bigadiç escort burhaniye escort gönen escort karesi escort susurluk escort ayvacık escort biga escort çan escort gelibolu escort yenice escort akçaabat escort araklı escort of escort ortahisar escort yomra escort karakoçan escort kovancılar escort altınordu escort fatsa escort perşembe escort ünye escort tavşanlı escort simav escort domaniç escort eğirdir escort yalvaç escort ardeşen escort cayeli escort fındıklı escort pazar escort afşin escort dulkadiroğlu escort Elbistan escort onikişubat escort pazarcık escort türkoğlu escort altınova escort çiftlikköy escort çınarcık escort bulancak escort espiye escort eynesil escort görele escort piraziz escort tirebolu escort yağlıdere escort sorgun escort sarıkaya escort çayıralan escort boğazlıyan escort akdağmadeni escort erbaa escort niksar escort turhal escort zile escort viranşehir escort suruç escort siverek escort karaköprü escort haliliye escort eyyübiye escort akçakale escort zara escort Yıldızeli escort suşehri escort şarkışla escort gemerek escort kozluk escort sason escort aziziye escort horasan escort oltu escort palandöken escort yakutiye escort ayancık escort boyabat escort gerze escort kaman escort mucur escort ermenek escort sarıveliler escort keskin escort yahşihan escort gerede escort göynük escort mengen escort mudurnu escort göynücek escort gümüşhacıköy escort merzifon escort suluova escort taşova escort bor escort çamardı escort ulukışla escort banaz escort eşme escort sivaslı escort havsa escort ipsala escort keşan escort osmancık escort sungurlu escort bahçe escort hasanbeyli escort kadirli escort toprakkale escort alaplı escort çaycuma escort ereğli escort kilimli escort başkale escort ipekyolu escort özalp escort tuşba escort kemah escort refahiye escort tercan escort üzümlü escort http://www.ddtshanghaiescort.com Antalya escort Bursa escort Mersin escort Aydın escort Balıkesir escort Çanakkale escort Kıbrıs escort Kütahya escort Manisa escort Muğla escort Tekirdağ escort Trabzon escort Yalova escort Isparta escort Maraş escort Ordu escort Rize escort Sivas escort Afyon escort Aksaray escort Giresun escort Şanlıurfa escort Yozgat escort Erzurum escort Amasya escort Çorum escort Tokat escort Uşak escort Van escort Bolu escort Burdur escort Kırşehir escort Niğde escort Osmaniye escort Zonguldak escort Düzce escort Edirne escort Erzincan escort Karabük escort Karaman escort Kastamonu escort Kırıkkale escort Kırklareli escort manavgat escort alanya escort belek escort aksu escort finike escort gazipaşa escort güllük escort kaş escort kemer escort kepez escort konyaaltı escort korkuteli escort kumluca escort lara escort muratpaşa escort serik escort gemlik escort gürsu escort inegöl escort iznik escort mudanya escort nilüfer escort orhangazi escort osmangazi escort yıldırım escort kuşadası escort didim escort nazilli escort söke escort efeler escort bandırma escort altıeylül escort edremit escort karesi escort susurluk escort bodrum escort gümbet escort turgutreis escort dalaman escort fethiye escort köyceğiz escort marmaris escort çerkezköy escort çorlu escort kapaklı escort süleymanpaşa escort meram escort anamur escort erdemli escort mezitli escort silifke escort tarsus escort akhisar escort salihli escort soma escort turgutlu escort girne escort lefkoşa escort biga escort çan escort gelibolu escort dinar escort emirdağ escort sandıklı escort merzifon escort suluova escort taşova escort yeşilyurt escort gerede escort mengen escort bucak escort kadirli escort osmancık escort sungurlu escort akçakoca escort ipsala escort keşan escort kilimli escort üzümlü escort aziziye escort palandöken escort yakutiye escort bulancak escort espiye escort tirebolu escort safranbolu escort lüleburgaz escort gediz escort simav escort tavşanlı escort elbistan escort fatsa escort ünye escort ardeşen escort çayeli escort birecik escort eyyübiye escort haliliye escort siverek escort suruç escort viranşehir escort kangal escort şarkışla escort suşehri escort yıldızeli escort erbaa escort niksar escort turhal escort akçaabat escort araklı escort of escort ortahisar escort sorgun escort www.elmasajeinfantil.com istanbul masaj salonu ankara masaj salonu izmir masaj salonu bursa masaj salonu antalya masaj salonu adana masaj salonu konya masaj salonu şanlıurfa masaj salonu gaziantep masaj salonu kocaeli masaj salonu mersin masaj salonu diyarbakır masaj salonu hatay masaj salonu manisa masaj salonu kayseri masaj salonu samsun masaj salonu balıkesir masaj salonu maraş masaj salonu van masaj salonu aydın masaj salonu tekirdağ masaj salonu sakarya masaj salonu denizli masaj salonu muğla masaj salonu bağcılar masaj salonu bahçelievler masaj salonu esenler masaj salonu esenyurt masaj salonu kadıköy masaj salonu kağıthane masaj salonu kartal masaj salonu küçükçekmece masaj salonu maltepe masaj salonu pendik masaj salonu sultangazi masaj salonu ümraniye masaj salonu üsküdar masaj salonu aliağa masaj salonu alsancak masaj salonu bayraklı masaj salonu bornova masaj salonu buca masaj salonu çeşme masaj salonu çiğli masaj salonu gaziemir masaj salonu karşıyaka masaj salonu konak masaj salonu menemen masaj salonu ödemiş masaj salonu torbalı masaj salonu çankaya masaj salonu keçiören masaj salonu mamak masaj salonu polatlı masaj salonu sincan masaj salonu alanya masaj salonu belek masaj salonu kaş masaj salonu kemer masaj salonu korkuteli masaj salonu lara masaj salonu manavgat masaj salonu serik masaj salonu side masaj salonu didim masaj salonu efeler masaj salonu kuşadası masaj salonu nazilli masaj salonu altıeylül masaj salonu bandırma masaj salonu edremit masaj salonu karesi masaj salonu susurluk masaj salonu gemlik masaj salonu gürsu masaj salonu inegöl masaj salonu mudanya masaj salonu nilüfer masaj salonu osmangazi masaj salonu yıldırım masaj salonu biga masaj salonu çan masaj salonu gelibolu masaj salonu adıyaman masaj salonu afyon masaj salonu ağrı masaj salonu aksaray masaj salonu amasya masaj salonu ardahan masaj salonu artvin masaj salonu bartın masaj salonu batman masaj salonu bayburt masaj salonu bilecik masaj salonu bingöl masaj salonu bitlis masaj salonu bolu masaj salonu burdur masaj salonu çanakkale masaj salonu çankırı masaj salonu çorum masaj salonu düzce masaj salonu edirne masaj salonu elazığ masaj salonu erzincan masaj salonu erzurum masaj salonu eskişehir masaj salonu giresun masaj salonu gümüşhane masaj salonu ığdır masaj salonu ısparta masaj salonu karabük masaj salonu karaman masaj salonu kastamonu masaj salonu kilis masaj salonu kırıkkale masaj salonu kırklareli masaj salonu kırşehir masaj salonu uşak masaj salonu kütahya masaj salonu malatya masaj salonu mardin masaj salonu nevşehir masaj salonu niğde masaj salonu ordu masaj salonu trabzon masaj salonu osmaniye masaj salonu rize masaj salonu siirt masaj salonu sinop masaj salonu sivas masaj salonu tokat masaj salonu karahayıt masaj salonu pamukkale masaj salonu nizip masaj salonu şahinbey masaj salonu şehitkamil masaj salonu antakya masaj salonu defne masaj salonu iskenderun masaj salonu darıca masaj salonu gebze masaj salonu gölcük masaj salonu izmit masaj salonu körfez masaj salonu akşehir masaj salonu beyşehir masaj salonu ereğli masaj salonu karatay masaj salonu meram masaj salonu selçuklu masaj salonu akhisar masaj salonu alaşehir masaj salonu soma masaj salonu turgutlu masaj salonu akdeniz masaj salonu anamur masaj salonu erdemli masaj salonu mezitli masaj salonu silifke masaj salonu tarsus masaj salonu toroslar masaj salonu yenişehir masaj salonu bodrum masaj salonu dalaman masaj salonu fethiye masaj salonu köyceğiz masaj salonu marmaris masaj salonu menteşe masaj salonu milas masaj salonu adapazarı masaj salonu serdivan masaj salonu atakum masaj salonu çarşamba masaj salonu ilkadım masaj salonu eyyübiye masaj salonu siverek masaj salonu viranşehir masaj salonu çerkezköy masaj salonu çorlu masaj salonu erbaa masaj salonu